Today 11953, Middle Island NY is count around 43 homes for sale at current average listing price of $566,215. Nearby neighborhoods of 11953 are Birchwood at Spring Lake, Artist Lake, Birchwood At Spring Lake, Strathmore on the Green, Birchwood, Birchwood@SpringLake, Coventry Manor, Fairview At Artist Lake, Spring Lake. Most of 11953 homes are 3 bedrooms with 2 bathrooms.